When it comes to fighting crime, most Americans think
of the FBI, state troopers, sheriffs' agencies, and police departments.
Much less known is a battle waged against certain kinds of criminals by
law officers whose badges identify them as "FDA-Special Agent."
The
men and women of FDA's Office of Criminal Investigations (OCI)
represent the consumers' front line against companies and individuals
who endanger the public's health. These criminals carry out unlawful
actions involving pharmaceuticals, foods, and other products regulated
by FDA. OCI focuses on violations of two laws—the Federal Food, Drug,
and Cosmetic Act and the Federal Anti-Tampering Act.
The Role of Special Agents
FDA's
Special Agents are stationed in multiple cities throughout the
continental United States and Puerto Rico. "We operate much like every
other federal law enforcement organization," says Terry Vermillion,
founding Director of OCI.
"We gather facts and present them
to the local U.S. Attorney's Office," he says. "The U.S. Attorney's
Office determines if and who will be prosecuted and OCI does the
investigative work to support the effort."
Special Agents:
- come to FDA mostly from other federal law
enforcement agencies, such as the U.S. Secret Service, Immigration and
Customs Enforcement, Postal Inspection Service, and Drug Enforcement
Administration
- bring years of prior federal criminal
investigative experience using traditional law enforcement methods,
professional contacts, and investigative techniques
- investigate
FDA-related crimes typically involving counterfeit, unapproved or
illegally diverted drugs, product tampering and substitution,
fraudulent health treatments, and allegations of fraud in new drug
applications and clinical trials
- have all the legal powers and capabilities of a well-equipped federal law enforcement organization
- have
federal statutory authority to obtain and execute arrest and search
warrants, carry firearms, and gather evidence to enforce United States
criminal law
- obtain specialized training as polygraph
examiners, computer forensics examiners, firearms instructors, and
technical surveillance specialists (if selected to do so)
A Collaborative Approach
FDA's Special Agents frequently investigate
criminal wrongdoing by large companies. If these investigations lead to
prosecution, the guilty officers and employees often receive federal
prison sentences, while the company can expect to receive
multimillion-dollar fines and restitution payments.
Many times when OCI initiates an investigation, other federal law
enforcement agencies that have a jurisdictional interest will join the
investigation. Many OCI cases have an international aspect. Since being
founded in 1992, OCI has developed good working relationships with many
foreign law enforcement counterparts, which aid in bringing criminals
outside the United States to justice.
Field investigations are enhanced by OCI's skilled investigative
analysts and technical specialists. In addition, the FDA's Forensic
Chemistry Center in Cincinnati, Ohio, provides valuable forensic
laboratory support by performing many different laboratory tests
related to suspect products involved in OCI investigations.
Examples of Investigations
In a typical year, FDA's Special Agents will
investigate about 1,000 criminal cases resulting in the arrests of
hundreds of suspected violators of public health laws.
On average, 200 criminal suspects are convicted each year as the
result of OCI investigations. From 1993 to present, OCI has made 4,593
arrests that resulted in 3,546 convictions and more than $5.7 billion
in fines and restitutions.
Overcharging for Zoladex:
OCI, working with several other agencies, uncovered a massive
conspiracy to overcharge Medicare, Medicaid, and other providers for a
drug for prostate cancer. The company paid more than $291 million in
fines and restitution to U.S. and state governments.
Illegal schemes for Serostim:
After OCI's Special Agents discovered a conspiracy to commit health
care fraud by bribing doctors and using other illegal methods to market
a treatment for AIDS, the company paid $704 million in criminal fines
and restitution to the U.S. Treasury.
Illegal promotion for OxyContin:
A major pharmaceutical company and three executives were convicted for
having falsely labeled, promoted, and illegally marketed a potent pain
reliever. The company paid fines and restitution totaling more than
$600 million.
Counterfeit drugs:
Beginning in 2005, an OCI counterfeit drug investigation has resulted
in the indictment of three businesses and 24 individuals for their
involvement in a $42 million conspiracy to manufacture and sell
counterfeit Lipitor and other drugs that they manufactured in a Costa
Rican lab. To date, 20 have been convicted.
Internet case:
On April 12, 2006, two men were sentenced in the Southern District of
Indiana Federal Court to 77 months incarceration after pleading guilty
to introducing a misbranded drug into interstate commerce.
Dextromethorphan (DXM), a cough suppressant, was sold over the Internet
through their Web site. This case started in 2005 when five young
people died after consuming DXM that they had ordered through the Web
site.
Clinical investigator fraud:
An investigation by OCI and the Veterans Affairs Office of Inspector
General resulted in the conviction of a Veterans Affairs' employee who
claimed to be a physician but in fact was not. This employee falsified
documentation of a clinical drug study and recklessly enrolled patients
who did not qualify under the study protocol. The defendant's criminal
negligence caused the death of one patient by falsely documenting the
results of blood chemistry analysis. The defendant was prosecuted and
sentenced to 71 months federal incarceration.
Food contamination:
The president of a cold storage distribution company was convicted and
sentenced to one year of federal incarceration. The company paid
hundreds of thousands of dollars in restitution for reboxing and
relabeling food tainted by an ammonia leak at the cold storage
facility. The contaminated food was delivered to an Illinois elementary
school, causing 43 students and staff to become hospitalized.
Illegal drug diversion:
In 2006, father and son owners and operators of a Florida
pharmaceutical wholesale distributorship were sentenced to 18 years and
25 years incarceration, respectively. They also paid more than $27
million in restitution for their involvement in an illicit diversion
scheme to buy and sell millions of dollars of illegally obtained
medications used to treat AIDS, cancer, hemophilia, and other ailments.
This scheme defrauded the Medicaid and Medicare programs of more than
$45 million.
Faulty surgical devices:
OCI agents were instrumental in securing the conviction of two company
executives who had fraudulently sold surgical sterilizing devices that
caused eye damage in 18 patients, one of whom lost sight in one eye.
Unlicensed flu vaccine:
In 2005, OCI agents arrested a person in Texas who administered
counterfeit influenza vaccine. Agents also brought about a federal
conviction of a smuggler who tried to sell the foreign, unlicensed flu
vaccine to hospitals.
Contaminated pet food:
In 2007, OCI initiated this investigation after FDA received numerous
reports that contaminated pet food was injuring and killing pets
nationwide. The products were contaminated with melamine, an ingredient
that is not approved for use in human or pet food. In February 2008, a
federal grand jury in Kansas City, Mo., indicted two Chinese companies
and their two top executives along with an American company and its
owners on charges including introducing adulterated and misbranded food
into interstate commerce. Pet food manufacturers had to recall more
than 150 brands of dog and cat food across the nation.
Fraudulent cures:
In 2005, OCI began investigating several Web sites selling fraudulent
cures for various diseases. The Web sites, which were operated by a
Dutch national, contained fictitious articles from nonexistent doctors,
fictitious testimonials from purported customers, and claims that the
products were FDA-approved when they were not. In December 2005, based
on evidence gathered by OCI, the defendant received but ignored a court
order prohibiting him from producing and selling his products. He was
indicted for criminal contempt, misbranding drugs, conspiracy, and mail
and wire fraud. In 2008, he was sentenced to 210 months incarceration.
How to Report Suspected Crime
OCI
has six field offices and six resident offices located throughout the
United States and Puerto Rico. Field offices are located in New York;
Washington, D.C.; Miami; Kansas City, Kan.; Chicago; and Los Angeles.
Resident offices are located in San Francisco; Austin, Texas; New
Orleans; San Juan, Puerto Rico; Atlanta; and Boston.
Consumers
can alert OCI to suspected criminal activity involving FDA-regulated
products by contacting the OCI office located in their region:
OCI headquarters: 240-276-9500
New York: 201-547-3851
Washington, D.C.: 240-276-9400
Miami: 954-476-5400
Los Angeles: 949-366-4600
Kansas City, Kan.: 913-384-7400
Chicago: 630-769-5520
San Francisco: 510-637-3480
Austin, Texas: 512-349-2599
New Orleans: 985-871-5152
San Juan, Puerto Rico: 787-281-4863
Atlanta: 404-253-2317
Boston: 978-531-5850
This article appears on FDA's Consumer Health Information Web page (www.fda.gov/consumer), which features the latest updates on FDA-regulated products. Sign up for free e-mail subscriptions at www.fda.gov/consumer/consumerenews.html.
For More Information
FDA Law Enforcers Crack Down on Illegal Botox Scammers
www.fda.gov/consumer/updates/botox081308.html
FDA's Office of Regulatory Affairs
www.fda.gov/ora/
Date Posted: July 23, 2007
Updated: August 13, 2008